The carriers we actually place.
Cribb Insurance Group is an independent agency in Bentonville. We are not tied to one company, which means the useful question is never "what does our carrier offer" — it is which of our markets fits your house, your drivers or your operation this year.
Below is every carrier we publish a coverage guide for, what it writes, and an honest note on what representing a carrier does and does not mean.
Short Answer
Cribb Insurance Group places coverage through more than forty markets across personal, commercial and recreational lines. This page lists the 28 carriers we publish a coverage guide for — a subset, not the whole list, because some markets are specialty or single-purpose and do not warrant their own page. Each guide explains what the carrier writes, where its financial strength rating actually sits, and where the coverage stops. The one thing worth reading before the list: holding an appointment is not the same as recommending a carrier. It means we can place and service the business. Whether it belongs on your account is a different question, and it is the one we are actually paid to answer.
Two things worth knowing first.
Availability is not a promise
Carrier eligibility varies by coverage type, location, property, class of business and underwriting, and it moves. A carrier that wants your account this quarter may not next year. That is normal, it is the reason an independent agency holds so many appointments, and it is why we would rather confirm a market will look at you before anyone gets attached to a name.
Appetite questions belong in a conversation
What we will not do on this page is publish which classes, roof ages, vehicles or operations a given carrier is taking right now. That is underwriting information, it changes constantly, and a page that got it wrong would be worse than no page. Ask Cribby or call us and we will check it properly against what each market is actually doing.
Filter by the coverage you need.
Every card links to that carrier's coverage guide. Where a carrier has individual line pages, the guide links down to them.
Acuity
Coverage guidePersonal and commercial lines from a single carrier, including business insurance, commercial auto and trucking alongside personal auto and home.
Aegis Specialty
Coverage guideA specialty property market for homes, mobile homes and dwellings, including risks that do not fit standard carrier guidelines.
Allstate
Coverage guideA national carrier writing personal auto, home and related household coverage.
American Modern
Coverage guideSpecialty property and recreational coverage, including manufactured homes, dwelling fire, watercraft and collector vehicles.
AssuranceAmerica
Coverage guideNon-standard personal auto, written for drivers whose history or vehicle does not fit a standard market.
Auto-Owners
Coverage guideAuto, home, life and business coverage across one of the broadest line sets we place, with a line page for each.
Berkshire Hathaway GUARD
Coverage guideSmall business coverage including workers compensation, businessowners policies and package options.
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate
Coverage guideCommercial coverage centered on workers compensation and related business lines. A separate company from GUARD, with its own underwriting and claims.
Branch
Coverage guidePersonal auto and home written together as a household package.
Chubb
Coverage guidePersonal and commercial coverage with options for higher-value homes, valuables and specialty exposures.
Cincinnati Insurance
Coverage guidePersonal and commercial lines, including higher-value homes and vehicles and a broad range of business coverage.
Farmers Union
Coverage guideA personal auto program that can carry cars, motorcycles, travel trailers, UTVs and motorhomes on one policy. Auto only.
Foremost
Coverage guidePersonal lines across standard and specialty property, including manufactured homes, motorcycles, recreational vehicles, vacant and seasonal dwellings.
GEICO
No coverage guide yetA national carrier known for personal auto, with business auto available for eligible accounts.
Hagerty
Coverage guideCollector vehicle coverage written on an agreed value basis, for classic and collector cars, motorcycles and watercraft.
Liberty Mutual
Coverage guideA national carrier writing personal auto and home, with commercial options for eligible accounts.
Lumen Select
Coverage guideA homeowners and property market available to eligible Arkansas households.
NAICO
Coverage guideCommercial lines only, built around construction, manufacturing, energy and service contractors, with a line page for each coverage.
National General
Coverage guidePersonal auto, recreational vehicle, specialty auto and business auto, including markets for drivers who do not fit a standard carrier.
Nationwide
Coverage guideAuto, home, life, farm and business coverage for households and businesses.
Obie
Coverage guideCoverage built for rental and investment property owners, including landlord and multi-unit exposures.
Progressive
Coverage guideAuto, home, motorcycle, recreational vehicle, boat, commercial auto and business coverage from a national carrier.
Steadily
Coverage guideLandlord and rental property coverage, including short-term rental exposures.
Stillwater
Coverage guideHomeowners, condominium, renters, landlord, auto and personal umbrella, with a small businessowners policy alongside. Each line has its own page.
The Hartford
Coverage guideAuto, home, umbrella and business coverage, including workers compensation for eligible accounts.
Tokio Marine HCC
Coverage guideAn admitted artisan contractor program: general liability, professional, pollution and excess liability plus contractors tools and equipment.
Travelers
Coverage guideAuto, home and business coverage from a long-established national carrier.
USLI
Coverage guideSpecialty small business coverage including professional and management liability, nonprofit and religious organizations, and specialty individual products.
No carriers match that coverage type. Select "All carriers" to reset the list.
Carrier representation, coverage availability and eligibility vary by product, location, risk detail and underwriting, and appointments change over time. Contact us to confirm current options for your situation.
Questions about the carriers we represent.
How many insurance carriers does Cribb Insurance Group represent?
Does representing a carrier mean Cribb Insurance recommends it?
Why does working with an independent agency that represents many carriers matter?
Can I get a quote from multiple carriers at once?
⭐ Follow Cribb Insurance Group in Google
Add us as a preferred source and our Arkansas insurance coverage shows up more often in your Google results.
One request. Every market that fits.
Send one quote request and we will compare the carriers that will actually look at your account — and tell you plainly if what you already have is better than what we can find. If a name on this list is the wrong fit for you, we would rather say so than write it.
1601 SW Regional Airport Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72713 📞 (479) 286-1066 ✉️ service@cribbinsurance.com 🕔 Mon–Thu 9:00–5:00
Fri 9:00–4:00
Cribb Insurance Group Inc. is an independent insurance agency licensed in Arkansas. Carrier names and logos shown on this page are marks of their respective owners, used nominatively to identify markets this agency may compare. We are not any of the companies listed, and this page is not endorsed, sponsored, reviewed or approved by them. Inclusion on this page identifies a market we can access; it is not a recommendation, an endorsement, or a statement that a carrier will write your account.
This page is informational only. It is not a policy, not an offer of insurance, and not a guarantee of coverage, availability, eligibility or price. Carrier representation, product availability, coverage terms and eligibility vary by state, by class of business, by policy and over time, are set by the carrier, and are subject to underwriting approval and to the terms, conditions, limits and exclusions of the policy actually issued. Appointments change; a carrier listed here may not be available when you apply.
No financial strength ratings, premium figures, rate estimates, savings figures or suggested coverage limits are published on this page. Where a carrier's coverage guide states a financial strength rating, that rating is an opinion of an insurer's ability to meet its ongoing insurance obligations, applies only to the rated company, does not transfer to affiliates or similarly named companies, is subject to change, and does not address claims-handling practices. Current ratings are at ambest.com.