Insurance Carriers Represented by Cribb Insurance
Cribb Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency in Bentonville, Arkansas. Instead of being tied to one company, our team helps families, drivers, homeowners, and business owners compare coverage across 40+ insurance carriers.
From auto and home insurance to commercial insurance, workers compensation, cyber liability, specialty property, and umbrella coverage, Cribb Insurance helps you compare options from trusted markets in one place.
Trust Cribb Insurance for insurance education, coverage tips, and answers to your questions. Add Cribb Insurance as a preferred source on Google →
Why carrier choice matters
- Compare multiple insurance companies through one local agency
- Review coverage, price, deductibles, limits, and eligibility
- Shop personal and commercial insurance markets
- Get guidance from licensed Cribb Insurance professionals
Personal Insurance
Compare auto, homeowners, renters, condo, umbrella, motorcycle, RV, boat, and specialty personal insurance options.
Business Insurance
Review general liability, BOP, commercial property, workers compensation, commercial auto, cyber, EPLI, and umbrella options.
Specialty Markets
Access markets for manufactured homes, vacant dwellings, specialty property, non-standard auto, niche business risks, and hard-to-place coverage.
One independent agency, many trusted insurance companies.
Cribb Insurance Group represents 40+ insurance carriers across personal and commercial lines. That gives our advisors more ways to compare coverage, price, underwriting fit, discounts, and long-term value for Northwest Arkansas customers.
Explore carriers by coverage type.
Use the filters below to browse carrier options for auto, home, life, business, and specialty coverage. Carrier eligibility varies by location, risk, underwriting, coverage type, and current market availability.
Strong auto markets with bundle opportunities.
Progressive, GEICO, National General, Liberty Mutual, and Nationwide are often useful auto-focused markets. Progressive and National General may become even more aggressive with rates when eligible customers bundle additional policies.
Many carriers prefer packaged policies.
Travelers, Nationwide, Auto-Owners, Cincinnati Insurance, Liberty Mutual, Stillwater, and The Hartford are often strongest when home and auto coverage are packaged together. In the current market, many carriers may limit stand-alone home options or favor bundled eligibility.
Acuity
Guide comingA highly rated carrier known for business insurance, commercial auto, trucking, personal auto, and home coverage options.
Aegis
Guide comingA specialty property market for homes, mobile homes,dwellings, and risks that may not fit standard carrier guidelines.
Allstate
Guide comingA national insurance carrier offering personal auto, home, and related coverage options for families.
American Modern
Guide comingA specialty insurer for manufactured homes, dwelling fire, watercraft, collector vehicles, and other niche property risks.
Auto-Owners
Guide comingA respected carrier offering auto, home, life, and business insurance with a strong service reputation.
Berkshire Hathaway GUARD
Guide comingCommercial insurance options for small businesses, including workers compensation, BOP, and package coverage.
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate
Guide comingCommercial coverage with a focus on workers compensation and other business protection lines.
Cincinnati Insurance
Guide comingPersonal and commercial lines coverage, including higher-value cars, homes and a broad range of business insurance options.
Foremost Signature/360/Star
Guide comingPersonal Lines Carrier that specializes higher-value auto and Home while offering a specialty personal-lines carrier for manufactured homes, motorcycles, RVs, vacant properties, seasonal homes, and more.
GEICO
Guide comingA national carrier known for personal auto insurance, with business auto options available for eligible customers.
Liberty Mutual
Coverage guideA national carrier offering personal auto, home, and related coverage options.
Lumen Select
Guide comingA homeowners and property market available to eligible Northwest Arkansas customers.
National General
Guide comingPersonal auto, RV, specialty auto, and business auto options, including flexible markets for drivers and risks that may not fit standard carriers. National General may become more aggressive when eligible customers bundle additional policies.
Nationwide
Guide comingA broad carrier writing auto, home, life, business, and farm coverage for households and businesses.
Progressive
Coverage guideAuto, home, motorcycle, RV, boat, commercial auto, and business insurance options from a major national carrier. Progressive may become even more competitive when eligible customers bundle additional policies.
Stillwater
Guide comingHome, auto, umbrella, and business coverage options, often a strong fit for homeowners, dwellings, and bundled personal or commercial needs.
The Hartford
Guide comingAuto, home, umbrella, and business insurance coverage from a nationally recognized carrier with strong options for both personal and commercial insurance customers.
Travelers
Coverage guideAuto, home, and business coverage from a long-established national insurance carrier.
USLI
Guide comingSpecialty commercial and professional liability coverage for niche industries and harder-to-place risks.
No carriers match that coverage type. Select “All carriers” to reset the list.
Carrier representation, coverage availability, and eligibility vary by product, location, risk details, and underwriting. The carriers listed here are representative of the markets Cribb Insurance Group accesses; carrier appointments and availability may change over time. Contact Cribb Insurance Group to confirm current options for your situation.
Questions About the Carriers We Represent
How many insurance carriers does Cribb Insurance Group represent?
Cribb Insurance Group is an independent agency that represents 40+ insurance carriers across personal and commercial lines, so customers can compare pricing and coverage from multiple companies through one Northwest Arkansas office.
Which insurance companies does Cribb Insurance Group work with in Arkansas?
Represented carriers include Progressive, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Auto-Owners, Allstate, Acuity, Cincinnati Insurance, Foremost, American Modern, The Hartford, National General, GEICO, Stillwater, and additional specialty and commercial markets. Carrier availability depends on coverage type, location, and eligibility.
Why does working with an independent agency that represents many carriers matter?
An independent agency can compare options from many insurance companies instead of being limited to one. Cribb Insurance Group can shop your coverage, limits, deductibles, and price across multiple carriers and help recommend the policy that fits your needs and budget.
Can I get a quote from multiple carriers at once?
Yes. You submit one request to Cribb Insurance Group and our team compares carrier options for you. Start a personal quote or commercial quote online, or call the Bentonville office at (479) 286-1066.
One Request. Multiple Insurance Companies.
Complete one quote request and a licensed Cribb Insurance advisor will compare options across multiple carriers to help find the right fit for your personal or business insurance needs.